If you haven’t bought a mattress recently, the choices available now can be overwhelming. Manufacturers produce a variety of styles, and online mattress stores have changed the landscape for many shoppers. Our partners at ConsumerAffairs researched the best mattress stores in Indianapolis to help narrow your choices and find a mattress that’s perfect for your sleep style.
Everyone deserves to make thoughtful, informed purchase decisions. The local guides provided on this website are free for consumers. RTV6 may receive compensation from our partners. Learn more.
No mattress is perfect for everyone. The one that works best for you depends on your sleeping position, your style and comfort preferences, whether you have back or joint pain and your budget.
The common idea that a firm mattress is the best for lower back pain isn’t accurate for everyone. The most important factor is whether the mattress provides the proper amount of support, and your body shape and weight may make other options a better choice. Go with what feels comfortable, and prepare to sleep on the mattress for several weeks before you can be sure it’s going to help — and not further damage — your back.
A mattress should keep your spine aligned to provide the most comfort and pain relief. You need to maintain correct posture when you’re sleeping because your back and muscles are repairing themselves from a long day of movement and activity. The best mattress firmness often depends on your hips: People with wider hips do better with a softer mattress, while those with smaller hips sleep better on a firm surface.
Manufacturers generally classify mattresses into three categories for firmness:
Soft mattresses tend to cushion sleepers, making them good options for anyone who sleeps on their side. The extra softness allows your hips and shoulders to sink in so the mattress supports your whole body. Smaller and medium-sized frames are also likely to have good results on a soft mattress. People larger than 230 to 250 pounds may find they sink too far into a soft mattress to be comfortable.
Medium-firm mattresses offer less cushioning than a soft mattress but more of a plush sleeping surface than a firm mattress. They can distribute weight evenly and support the entire body during sleep. These mattresses are usually a good compromise for people who switch positions regularly while they sleep.
Firm mattresses are great for spine alignment and for heavier Indianapolis residents who don’t want to feel like they’re falling into a bed that’s too pliable. Stomach sleepers also do better on a firm mattress because the surface is more stable.
If you share a bed with your partner, consider their sleeping style when choosing a mattress as well. Some mattress brands design adjustable mattresses that allow each person to set the firmness to their desired level, which solves the problem of each person preferring a different mattress.
In addition to firmness, consider the style of mattress that is most comfortable for you. While some Indianapolis residents choose to purchase a traditional innerspring mattress, many people opt for the benefits provided by newer designs such as memory foam mattresses and hybrid mattresses.
Mattress types in Indianapolis
Innerspring mattresses have coil supports inside the bed that provide support and make the bed springy
People who need extra support
Shoppers on a budget
$700 - $950
Memory foam mattresses have a high-density foam support layer and at least one layer of foam on top that contours to your body
Heavier sleepers who need additional support
People who want a soft mattress
$600 - $1,200
Latex mattresses are similar to memory foam mattresses but use foam layers made of all-natural latex
Good for pain relief and spinal alignment
People who have allergies
$1,500 - $2,500
Hybrid mattresses combine two support systems, usually an innerspring or coil interior with a memory foam top surface
Shoppers looking for the best qualities of innercoil and memory foam mattresses
Those who want a soft mattress with additional support
$1,200 - $2,000
Bed in a box vs. in-store mattresses
Customers in Indianapolis can buy nearly anything online now, and that includes mattresses. Online bed-in-a-box companies sell mattresses that are compressed, vacuum-sealed and shipped to your home. The mattresses expand over a few hours after being unpacked.
Buying a mattress online means you don’t have the opportunity to test the mattress until it arrives at your home, but most companies offer extended trials of 100 nights or more, during which you can return the mattress at no charge if you’re not satisfied. Mattress-in-a-box companies are usually able to offer lower prices by selling directly to consumers and are efficient options for online shoppers.
Traditional mattress stores have some advantages over online stores. In addition to letting you test a bed before buying it, brick-and-mortar retailers carry various brands and more styles of mattresses, giving shoppers a more extensive selection. Many traditional stores also offer delivery and mattress setup, either for free or a small fee, and may dispose of your old mattress when delivering a new one.
What is the average mattress price in Indianapolis?
The cost of a new mattress in Indianapolis varies widely. They can be purchased for as little as $500 and as much as $5,000. Some of the factors affecting the cost of your mattress include:
Whether you need to buy a box spring with your mattress — not all mattresses require them, but traditional coil or spring mattresses do
The type of mattress you choose — hybrid mattresses and latex mattresses typically cost more
The brand and retailer from which you buy your mattress
Whether you have to pay for delivery and/or shipping
Whether you have to pay to have your old mattress removed
Additional costs such as financing interest charges or extended warranties
Look for sales and discounts. Traditional and online mattress shops often reduce prices during holidays such as July 4th, Memorial Day and President’s Day.
The Federal Trade Commission’s guide to mattress buying warns shoppers to be alert for used mattresses that are covered with new materials and caution consumers to always check mattress tags.
How to dispose of a mattress in Indianapolis
Once you have your new mattress, it’s time to get rid of your old one. Some companies offer free mattress removal when delivering your new mattress, and others may charge a fee of up to $150 for mattress removal.
The Indianapolis Department of Public Works picks up mattresses and other furniture on specific days for no charge. If you’re unsure when your pickup day is, the department’s website has a tool that finds when the city collects your trash.
How to buy a mattress in Indianapolis
Once you have an idea of what type of mattress you like, it’s time to narrow the field to choose a specific mattress. Some things to consider when making a decision are:
Customer reviews: While no mattress is perfect for everyone, reviews from other shoppers let you know about the company’s customer service and whether the mattress retains its firmness over time.
Warranty information: Ask if the company offers a warranty on its mattresses and check to see what the warranty covers. Find out if you must pay shipping when returning a mattress on a warranty claim.
Return and shipping policies, including no-risk trials: It can take up to 30 days to become accustomed to a new mattress, so be sure the company offers a risk-free trial period so you can return it if you’re not satisfied.
Materials used in the mattress: This is especially crucial if you have allergies or sensitivities.
After you receive the mattress, check the care and maintenance instructions — some companies may not honor your warranty if you don’t use a box spring, for instance. You should also ensure the mattress meets the federal standards for flammability, which are set by the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission.
Saatva Mattress sells hybrid mattresses that feature both innercoil and foam layers. The company includes free delivery and mattress removal with the purchase of a new mattress. Saatva also provides a 120-night trial. Many Indianapolis customers were apprehensive about purchasing a mattress online but ended up being pleased with the product they received.
Mattresses and toppers sold by Luma Sleep are created with 100 percent natural latex, which provides comfort and support without allergens and toxins. It’s an online company that provides personalized mattress selections to Indianapolis shoppers who want a customized experience when choosing their sleeping surface. The company also sells bed frames and other accessories.
Select Comfort - Sleep Number
Four Indianapolis Select Comfort - Sleep Number stores are available for customers who prefer to lay on a mattress before buying it. The national brand offers a 100-night trial and a 25-year limited warranty. The brand is known for its mattresses that allow each individual customer to measure their specific sleep number before buying.
Purple’s patented Smart Comfort Grid is designed to provide superior support to help people sleep better. The company sells two styles of mattress, including one that allows you to choose between soft, medium or firm. Purple also sells an adjustable base for its mattresses. Indianapolis customers praise the company’s innovative design.
Casper is an online mattress company with options for Indianapolis sleepers. They offer free delivery and returns, a 10-year warranty and a 100-day free trial. They are environmentally aware, pledging never to use materials that are harmful to the ozone of the planet. Reviews from Indianapolis appreciate the multiple styles of mattress to fit different budgets.
Nectar offers a 365-night trial period and a warranty that lasts for as long as you own the mattress. The company also provides free shipping and returns, and customers can opt for setup and mattress disposal for a fee. Indianapolis reviews praise Nectar mattresses for giving them a better night’s sleep for an affordable cost.
Our partners independently research and analyze the companies mentioned in our guides and work with subject matter experts to add valuable information that helps consumers make smart purchase decisions. Our partners will not include companies on these guides that do not meet specific quality standards. The compensation we receive from our partners may impact how and where companies appear on our site, including the order in which they appear.
Our partners independently research companies, and use editorial discretion to award companies with special recognition (i.e. Best Value) based on their staff’s judgement or subject matter expert’s judgement. Our partners do this to help you identify companies that will meet your specific buying needs, and do not receive compensation for these designations.